‘McCarty’s delivery of the famous speech in which he recounts Cleopatra’s greeting of Antony on a perfumed, jeweled barge is so vivid you can almost see it.’ St. Louis Post-Dispatch ‘A splendid job as Enobarbus…’ BroadwayWorld.com
'McCarty's performance is the most fun to watch. His Roach is manic, childlike, and corny until the moment when he explodes. The fellow convicts' interplay is the heart of the show... ' KC Metropolis ' His nervous, ferret-like energy makes it seem that Roach is on the verge of bursting out of his skin at any moment. Or that if he just keeps talking, his execution day will never come.' Kansas City Star
‘Riveting… stunning credibility’ Meet Me in the Greenroom ‘…breathtaking, a tale of friendship and morality’ Sullivan County Democrat
‘Jeffrey M. Bender and Conan McCarty are brilliant as Dogberry and Verges and their shtick is very Monty Python meets The Three Stooges.’ QOnStage ‘His timing is hilariously impeccable…’ The Daily Record ‘… strong supporting work as Dogberry’s sputtering assistant…’ NJ Arts
‘… an intensely human, grounded performance..’ Edge Philadelphia ‘… a commanding presence, surprisingly likable and even a little endearing as the former commander in chief.’ Theatre Mania ‘… perfect squinting eyes…’ NY Times
‘The rock solid team of Fred Arsenault as Captain Gower and Conan McCarty as Captain Fluellen (Petruchio and his servant Grumio in ‘Shrew’) demonstrated what repertory performance is all about.’ ShakespearesTribe.com ‘Saucy, bold, and stubbornly dignified as Welsh Captain Fluellen.’ SantaCruz.com
‘Conan McCarty in particular gives a rich and thoughtful performance as the supportive Walt.’ Off Broadway Reviews
‘Chilling as the vicious father…’ Madison Patch ‘… a scary figure of pure ignorant evil…’ Talkin’Broadway.com ‘… the way he struts down the steps shows his confidence that he can’t lose in 1935 Alabama.’ Star Ledger
'McCarty is fantastic, with a lilt in his gait..' Journal Inquirer '...scrappy and scurrilous, Mr. McCarty is gruff, and though cantankerous, shows a true and deep love for his daughter..' Broadway World CT '...old goat of a father brought to stinging life..' Bonnie's Blog: The Balcony and Beyond